The 25 'most romantic' restaurants in Tampa Bay, according to Yelp

Earlier this week, Yelp released its annual list of "100 most romantic" restaurants in the country, and a couple Tampa Bay spots made the list.

To come up with the rankings, Yelp went through a large number of reviews mentioning the words “romantic,” “Valentine’s Day” and “date night” between Jan. 1, 2019 and Jan. 14, 2020, and ranked the restaurants in order along with other key factors like volume of reviews, and total ratings.

While this national list was certainly interesting, we wanted to know more about what local Yelpers thought about Tampa Bay restaurants. So, we reached out to the company and they gave us an exclusive list of the "most romantic" spots located in Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Manatee counties.  You may notice that this list is a little different than the national ranking, and that's because what you see here is an all-time list, that includes reviews from the beginning of Yelp Tampa Bay all the way through today.

So, if you haven't made and any RSVPs yet, here are a few spots to try.

Scroll down to view images
24. Cena
1208 E. Kennedy Blvd., Tampa, (813) 374-8840
“It was my first time there, and the experience was amazing. Everything was delicious. The seafood pasta was delicious along with an amazing Tiramisu to finish the dinner. The staff was delightful. Can't wait to come back.”- Gabby L.
Photo via Cena/Yelp

24. Cena

1208 E. Kennedy Blvd., Tampa, (813) 374-8840
“It was my first time there, and the experience was amazing. Everything was delicious. The seafood pasta was delicious along with an amazing Tiramisu to finish the dinner. The staff was delightful. Can't wait to come back.”- Gabby L.

Photo via Cena/Yelp
23. La Casa Della Pasta
5273 Ehrlich Rd., Tampa, (813) 961-1012
“The food at Cena is really good. It's off the beaten path and flies below the Tampa food radar but is definitely one of the best restaurants in town.”- Jammie S.
Photo via Christina G./Yelp

23. La Casa Della Pasta

5273 Ehrlich Rd., Tampa, (813) 961-1012
“The food at Cena is really good. It's off the beaten path and flies below the Tampa food radar but is definitely one of the best restaurants in town.”- Jammie S.

Photo via Christina G./Yelp
22. The Stein & Vine
827 W. Bloomingdale Ave., Brandon, (813) 655-4786
“The Stein & Vine doesn't look like much sitting in a Big Lots plaza with a sign overhead that reads "Pub,” but it is one of the best restaurants in Brandon. I'm not saying it is good for you, but it is delicious.”- April H.
Photo via Karen P./Yelp

22. The Stein & Vine

827 W. Bloomingdale Ave., Brandon, (813) 655-4786
“The Stein & Vine doesn't look like much sitting in a Big Lots plaza with a sign overhead that reads "Pub,” but it is one of the best restaurants in Brandon. I'm not saying it is good for you, but it is delicious.”- April H.

Photo via Karen P./Yelp
21. Brick & Mortar
539 Central Ave., Saint Petersburg, (727) 822-6540
“New future date-night spot!!! The short rib fat noodles and the burger with bacon onion jam were some of the best bites I've had in Tampa Bay.”- Tyler S.
Photo via Matt C./Yelp

21. Brick & Mortar

539 Central Ave., Saint Petersburg, (727) 822-6540
“New future date-night spot!!! The short rib fat noodles and the burger with bacon onion jam were some of the best bites I've had in Tampa Bay.”- Tyler S.

Photo via Matt C./Yelp
20. Craft Street Kitchen
3153 Curlew Rd., Oldsmar, (727) 314-4270
“This is one of my favorite go-to American cuisine restaurants in the area. The food is always fresh and delicious. Yes, there is going to be a wait if you're walking in on a Thursday/Friday night, but if you strategize just right you can easily snag a seat at the bar or one of the first-come-first-serve high tops.”- Jennifer J. 
Photo via Milack T./Yelp

20. Craft Street Kitchen

3153 Curlew Rd., Oldsmar, (727) 314-4270
“This is one of my favorite go-to American cuisine restaurants in the area. The food is always fresh and delicious. Yes, there is going to be a wait if you're walking in on a Thursday/Friday night, but if you strategize just right you can easily snag a seat at the bar or one of the first-come-first-serve high tops.”- Jennifer J.

Photo via Milack T./Yelp
19. Donatello Restaurant
232 N. Dale Mabry Hwy., Tampa, (813) 875-6660
“If you're looking for a romantic fine dining experience in Tampa that's actually worth the cost, you won't be disappointed at Donatello. From the roses on the tables, the warm pink glow, and the perfectly attentive service from the tuxedoed staff, to the impeccable Northern Italian dishes, every part of the experience will impress you and transport you to another time and place.”- Alisha D. 
Photo via Rob M./Yelp

19. Donatello Restaurant

232 N. Dale Mabry Hwy., Tampa, (813) 875-6660
“If you're looking for a romantic fine dining experience in Tampa that's actually worth the cost, you won't be disappointed at Donatello. From the roses on the tables, the warm pink glow, and the perfectly attentive service from the tuxedoed staff, to the impeccable Northern Italian dishes, every part of the experience will impress you and transport you to another time and place.”- Alisha D.

Photo via Rob M./Yelp
18. Rooster & the Till
6500 N. Florida Ave., Tampa, (813) 374-8940
“This is our go to restaurant for any anniversary or birthday celebration! The food is always a hit and something we crave but the thing that makes us keep coming back is the absolutely phenomenal service.” -Attiya H. 
Photo via Tasha M./Yelp

18. Rooster & the Till

6500 N. Florida Ave., Tampa, (813) 374-8940
“This is our go to restaurant for any anniversary or birthday celebration! The food is always a hit and something we crave but the thing that makes us keep coming back is the absolutely phenomenal service.” -Attiya H.

Photo via Tasha M./Yelp
17. Nabruzzi Trattoria
6062 Van Dyke Rd., Lutz, (813) 304-2583
“Very surprised I have not tried this gem earlier! Great atmosphere, staff was friendly and the food was to die for.” -Lara T. 
Photo via John I./Yelp

17. Nabruzzi Trattoria

6062 Van Dyke Rd., Lutz, (813) 304-2583
“Very surprised I have not tried this gem earlier! Great atmosphere, staff was friendly and the food was to die for.” -Lara T.

Photo via John I./Yelp
16. Noble Crust
8300 4th St. N., St Petersburg, (727) 329-6041
“Oh my gee. This is one of my absolute places in St. Pete!!! I've been here about 3 or 4 times now and I have yet to be disappointed!!” -Ali T. 
Photo via Noble Crust/Yelp

16. Noble Crust

8300 4th St. N., St Petersburg, (727) 329-6041
“Oh my gee. This is one of my absolute places in St. Pete!!! I've been here about 3 or 4 times now and I have yet to be disappointed!!” -Ali T.

Photo via Noble Crust/Yelp
15. Snapper's Sea Grill
5895 Gulf Blvd., St. Pete Beach, (727) 367-3550
“Dinner was delicious. Thoughtful seafood dishes unlike your normal beach fare. Our waiter was wonderful and even put up with my annoying dad.”-Gene S. 
Photo via Rhonda M./Yelp

15. Snapper's Sea Grill

5895 Gulf Blvd., St. Pete Beach, (727) 367-3550
“Dinner was delicious. Thoughtful seafood dishes unlike your normal beach fare. Our waiter was wonderful and even put up with my annoying dad.”-Gene S.

Photo via Rhonda M./Yelp
14. Da Sesto Italiano Ristorante e Vino
7201 66th St. N., Pinellas Park, (727) 209-2695
“What a meal - beginning to end. Really great italian hospitality. Great service. Food made with love. No complaints!”- Corie Y. 
Photo via Crystal H./Yelp

14. Da Sesto Italiano Ristorante e Vino

7201 66th St. N., Pinellas Park, (727) 209-2695
“What a meal - beginning to end. Really great italian hospitality. Great service. Food made with love. No complaints!”- Corie Y.

Photo via Crystal H./Yelp
13. Bella's Italian Cafe 
1413 S. Howard Ave., Ste. 100, Tampa, (813) 254-3355
“Bella's is a staple in both the traditional Italian dinner routine and the late night South Tampa life. Consistently indulgent Dishes with long-time amazingly attentive servers makes Bella's a solid 5 star restaurant.”- Tina D. 
Photo via Lorrenzo G./Yelp

13. Bella's Italian Cafe

1413 S. Howard Ave., Ste. 100, Tampa, (813) 254-3355
“Bella's is a staple in both the traditional Italian dinner routine and the late night South Tampa life. Consistently indulgent Dishes with long-time amazingly attentive servers makes Bella's a solid 5 star restaurant.”- Tina D.

Photo via Lorrenzo G./Yelp
12. Samurai Blue Sushi & Sake Bar
1600 E. 8th Ave., Ste. C208, Ybor City, (813) 242-6688
“Love this place, they have the best Sushi in Tampa and they have the best bang for your buck lunch special in Ybor. I highly recommend.”- Meh M. 
Photo via Steve A./Yelp

12. Samurai Blue Sushi & Sake Bar

1600 E. 8th Ave., Ste. C208, Ybor City, (813) 242-6688
“Love this place, they have the best Sushi in Tampa and they have the best bang for your buck lunch special in Ybor. I highly recommend.”- Meh M.

Photo via Steve A./Yelp
11. Indigenous Restaurant
239 S. Links Ave., Sarasota, (941) 706-4740
“One of the best meals I have had in awhile. Fresh, innovative, and local. Chef is very connected to what he's doing.”- Lisa C. 
Photo via Judi G./Yelp

11. Indigenous Restaurant

239 S. Links Ave., Sarasota, (941) 706-4740
“One of the best meals I have had in awhile. Fresh, innovative, and local. Chef is very connected to what he's doing.”- Lisa C.

Photo via Judi G./Yelp
10. Osteria Natalina
3215 S. MacDill Ave., Tampa, (813) 831-1210
“Fantastic Authentic Italian food! The restaurant is a skinny small space with limited seating and very reminiscent of a true Italian osteria.”- Elle S. 
Photo via Osteria Natalina/Yelp

10. Osteria Natalina

3215 S. MacDill Ave., Tampa, (813) 831-1210
“Fantastic Authentic Italian food! The restaurant is a skinny small space with limited seating and very reminiscent of a true Italian osteria.”- Elle S.

Photo via Osteria Natalina/Yelp
8. Ulele
1810 N. Highland Ave., Tampa, (813) 999-4952
“This place is perfect for any occasion whether it's for a birthday, anniversary, date night or just wanting to have a nice meal out! I love the Native American and Florida waters inspiration for this place.”- Julie J. 
Photo via Rebecca G./Yelp

8. Ulele

1810 N. Highland Ave., Tampa, (813) 999-4952
“This place is perfect for any occasion whether it's for a birthday, anniversary, date night or just wanting to have a nice meal out! I love the Native American and Florida waters inspiration for this place.”- Julie J.

Photo via Rebecca G./Yelp
7. Cafe Ponte
13505 Icot Blvd., Ste. 214, Clearwater, (727) 538-5768
“Guys please order the ahi tuna thing for appy... I have eaten at many places but this one beats them all! It's divine! The layers are fresh and crunchy and wholesome! Can't wait to be back! This place is amazing!”- Zermin A. 
Photo via Mailoha A./Yelp

7. Cafe Ponte

13505 Icot Blvd., Ste. 214, Clearwater, (727) 538-5768
“Guys please order the ahi tuna thing for appy... I have eaten at many places but this one beats them all! It's divine! The layers are fresh and crunchy and wholesome! Can't wait to be back! This place is amazing!”- Zermin A.

Photo via Mailoha A./Yelp
6. Annata Wine
300 Beach Dr. NE., St. Petersburg, (727) 851-9582
“Absolutely the best wine and cheese place in St. Pete.  Want an upscale dining experience, with a choice of the most incredible wine list?  Adult crowds?  This is the place.  you can't go wrong with anything on the menu.  Highly recommended!”- Alex P. 
Photo via Joe S./Yelp

6. Annata Wine

300 Beach Dr. NE., St. Petersburg, (727) 851-9582
“Absolutely the best wine and cheese place in St. Pete. Want an upscale dining experience, with a choice of the most incredible wine list? Adult crowds? This is the place. you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Highly recommended!”- Alex P.

Photo via Joe S./Yelp
5. Pia's Trattoria
3054 Beach Blvd., Gulfport, (727) 327-2190
”Love at first sight. No. Bite.Love at first sight, soulmates at first bite!” - Lorraine N. 
Photo via Anita S./Yelp

5. Pia's Trattoria

3054 Beach Blvd., Gulfport, (727) 327-2190
”Love at first sight. No. Bite.Love at first sight, soulmates at first bite!” - Lorraine N.

Photo via Anita S./Yelp
4. Ciro’s 
2109 Bayshore Blvd., Tampa, (813) 251-0022
“This was truly an experience! To the secret code to get to the private booth which includes accent pillows and your own personal dimmer to set your own mood to lively bar area that is meant to resemble a speakeasy for the prohibition era. Innovative yet classy with a splash of individuality is what Ciro's is all about.” - Isaiah G.
Photo via Chesty P./Yelp

4. Ciro’s

2109 Bayshore Blvd., Tampa, (813) 251-0022
“This was truly an experience! To the secret code to get to the private booth which includes accent pillows and your own personal dimmer to set your own mood to lively bar area that is meant to resemble a speakeasy for the prohibition era. Innovative yet classy with a splash of individuality is what Ciro's is all about.” - Isaiah G.

Photo via Chesty P./Yelp
Page 1 of 2

Join the Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Press Club

At a time when local-based reporting is critical, support from our readers is essential to our future.